Why Many Art Lovers Prefer Abstract Art Over Realistic Art

It’s a common misconception that the majority of art collectors gravitate towards abstract art over realistic art. However, this is a belief based more on academic and critical perceptions rather than a widespread preference among the general population. To explore why some art enthusiasts choose abstract art, let's delve deeper into the factors at play and examine the statistics and experiences that support this preference.

Academic Influence and Critical Perceptions

Abstract and non-objective art have indeed been favored by the academic and critical art world for several decades. This influence has certainly shaped the activities of 'serious' art collectors. However, these collectors constitute a small fraction of the overall art market. According to my extensive experience—over 40 years of dealing with art in major markets in both coasts of the U.S.—the bulk of art purchases are made by regular individuals whose primary motivations may be quite different from those of collectors.

Dealing with Regular Art Buyers

Many regular people buy art for purely practical reasons such as needing a canvas to fill a wall, enhancing their home decor, or simply because they appreciate the aesthetics. In this group, realistic and impressionistic art tend to be the preferred genres. Over the years, from my experience as an art dealer in some of the country's largest centers, I’ve observed a clear trend favoring these styles.

The Practical Draw of Realism and Impressionism

Despite the preference for realism and impressionism among many buyers, it is important to note that non-objective art is not entirely absent. It is often chosen because it offers appealing design qualities and doesn’t necessarily demand a detailed and prolonged interaction from the viewer. For instance, a painting with vivid colors or intricate patterns can serve as an attractive backdrop in a room without drawing excessive attention. This ease of assimilation and integration into the environment makes non-objective art a popular choice for those seeking to enhance their living spaces without major disruption.

Contrasting Preferences

Abstract and non-representational art can indeed offer a blend of visual elements that seamlessly integrate with one's surroundings. This is why it is frequently featured in decor magazines and photography for rooms. The essence of abstract art often lies in its ability to blend and not overshadow the furniture and other elements of a room.

Reasons for Preference

There are several reasons why some individuals might prefer abstract art over realistic art:

Legitimate Liking: Some individuals genuinely appreciate the sophistication and creativity of abstract art. They find it commercially appealing and aesthetically pleasing.

Herd Following Critical Judments: Certain collectors and buyers follow critical appraisals and trends, which often favor abstract art in the contemporary art world. This can influence their preferences and purchases.

Decorational Convenience: Many people seek a type of art that complements their existing decor without significant disruption. Non-representational art can provide this convenience and flexibility.

While these factors contribute to a preference for abstract art, it is not at the expense of realistic art, which remains a popular choice among a significant portion of the art market.

Ultimately, the choice between abstract and realistic art depends on personal taste and the specific needs of the buyer. Both styles have their unique appeal and value in the art world.