The Unmistaken Differences Between an Opera Singer's and a Layman's Experience

Opera is a rich and complex art form that can be deeply moving for both performing artists and audiences. For many enthusiasts, the experience of watching a professional opera can be a joyous and emotionally engaging one. But how does this experience differ from that of a professional opera singer? This article delves into the unique insights and perspectives of both performers and casual spectators, exploring the subtle differences that make each experience special.

Opéra as a Layman's Experience

A layman opera lover feels a deep sense of connection to the experience, even without being a professional singer. I, for one, have a collection of opera arias and choruses on my iTunes, and I often find myself singing along in my car during solitary moments. This forms a personal connection to the music that is hard to achieve through other means.

One of the greatest joys in this hobby is watching a professional opera performance. Knowing the storyline and being able to understand much of the language, often with subtitles, makes the experience even more profound. There is an extra dimension to hearing a favorite aria sung by a different voice, adding a layer of enjoyment that is unique to the layman opera fan.

The emotional impact of a production can take on unexpected aspects. I once attended a production of Tosca where we were situated at the back in the cheap seats and saw the soprano fall onto a mattress behind the set. This moment transformed the tragic nature of the scene into light-hearted entertainment, resulting in pure enjoyment with no tears. This blend of emotion and levity is something that a professional singer, who often has to maintain focus on technical aspects, may not fully appreciate.

Professional Singer's Perspective

Professional opera singers bring a unique set of skills to the stage, and their experiences in the audience are quite different from those of the general public. Training as a professional singer often involves a focus on technical aspects, such as pitch control and vocal delivery, which can sometimes overshadow the broader artistic elements of an opera performance.

When attending an opera, a professional singer may be more critical, focusing on vocal performances and any potential technical issues. While a layman may be moved by the overall story and emotional impact, a professional might be drawn to specific vocal performances and the execution of the complex demands of the role.

For instance, I recall a situation where a fellow singer and lover of opera was so focused on technical vocal performances that he avoided attending an opera performance before the show had even begun. He was concerned that he would only be focused on vocal faults of the lead tenor, missing the broader musical and dramatic aspects of the performance. This story underscores the different ways in which opera can be appreciated and experienced, highlighting the value of both a critical and a more emotional approach.

The Pleasure of Performing

For those who perform, the process of preparing for and participating in an opera goes beyond the stage. The dedication, hard work, and long hours that go into a production can be intense, but the joy of performing cannot be overstated. Whether it's a large-scale production or a smaller-scale tour, the experience of the stage can be incredibly fulfilling.

As someone who has worked in various capacities in the opera world, including as a director, music director, stage director, and accompanist, I understand the dedication that goes into making a production successful. Running our own opera company for over twenty years and still singing professionally in church music demonstrates the sustained passion and commitment required in this field.

My late husband and I believed in the power of opera to connect people through emotion and storytelling. We fostered a love of the art form within our community, and the joy we found in performing and directing lives on through our work.

Conclusion

The experience of an opera performance is multifaceted and deeply personal. For professionals, it is a blend of technical skill, emotional engagement, and the joy of creating something beautiful. For laymen, it is a profound connection to the music and storytelling that can transcend language and cultural barriers.

Whether you are a professional singer or a dedicated layman, the art of opera offers endless opportunities for enjoyment and appreciation. Understanding these unique experiences can deepen one's appreciation of this vibrant and timeless art form.