The Role of Ghostwriters in the Music Industry: Evaluating Artistry

The question of whether a music artist who uses ghostwriters to create their lyrics should be considered a real artist has long been a point of contention. Traditionally, the ability to write one's own material has been seen as a hallmark of true artistry, but the reality is more complex. Artists today have a variety of roles in their creative processes, and the use of ghostwriters is increasingly common and accepted.

Defining the Artist's Role

When evaluating whether a music artist is a 'real' artist despite using ghostwriters, it is important to recognize the multifaceted nature of an artist's role. An artist is not just a lyricist; they are often a performer, a singer, a dancer, a performer of an instrument, a creator of a buzz, and a public figure. Even when it comes to writing lyrics, an artist may contribute more than just the words themselves. For instance, they might develop the concepts, stories, and even the overall themes behind the songs, even if the exact words are written by someone else.

Historical Precedents

This practice of using ghostwriters is nothing new. In the 1970s, many rock and pop stars relied on professional songwriters to write their lyrics while they remained the creative leaders and visionaries of the music. Similarly, in the realm of literature, prolific authors like James Patterson have ghostwriters to assist them in bringing their creative visions to life. In the case of painting, artists like Thomas Kinkade also relied on assistant painters to create much of their work, though they remained the primary creators and visionaries.

The Changing Landscape

The music industry has transformed over the years, and with it, the perception of artistry has evolved. Traditionally, if an artist was known to have used ghostwriters, it could negatively impact their reputation and sales. However, the current landscape is quite different. Artists like Tekashi 69, who has faced controversies and legal issues, still manage to maintain a strong following and generate significant sales. Similarly, Drake, a well-known artist with a history of using ghostwriters, continues to be a major player in the industry, attracting fans and driving sales.

The New Measure of Artistry

These changes reflect a shift in the way the music industry values artistry. Today, the focus is no longer on the label of 'real artist'; rather, it is on the ability to generate money and revenue. The game is now about creating content that resonates with audiences and drives commercial success. This means that while the traditional methods of artistry are still important, the ability to connect with fans and sell music is becoming the primary measure of success.

Conclusion

The use of ghostwriters in the music industry does not imply a lack of artistry. Instead, it reflects the growing complexity of the modern artist's role in the creative process. Artistry today is not defined solely by the ability to write one's own lyrics but by the ability to engage with fans, create resonant music, and generate significant financial success. As the industry continues to evolve, so too will the definition of 'real artistry,' but one thing remains clear: the focus is on commercial success and creative impact.