The Complexity of Cosmology: Why It's Incoherent and Frought with Alternative Theories

Introduction

Imagine trying to understand the mind of God during the creation of the universe. The quest for comprehending cosmology, or the study of the origin and evolution of the universe, is inherently complex and fraught with a myriad of alternative theories. This article explores why cosmology is such an intricate field, focusing on its incoherence, the limitations of our current theories, and the challenges it presents.

The Incoherence of Cosmology

One might argue that the incoherence of cosmology is not a flaw but, rather, a gift. It invites exploration, hypothesis, and the continual refinement of our understanding. In the realm of physics, there are no certainties; only constrained approximations. This is what makes cosmology such an exciting and dynamic field. The fact that we cannot claim to have a complete and unified theory of everything (TOE) is more indicative of the vastness of the universe and the limitations of our current understanding.

Limited Understanding and Alternative Theories

Scientists often fall into the trap of circular logic when they claim to have a well-understood theory of everything or use intentionally exclusive loops. This is reminiscent of the methods used by Scientology, which manipulates information to maintain control over its followers. In cosmology, the quest for a TOE is fruitless unless we first resolve the underpinnings of physics.

The underpinnings of physics—such as causality and the nature of time and space—are not yet fully described. The concept of evolving causality cannot be measured without affecting the flux, a point that underscores the inherent limitations in our ability to fully grasp the fabric of the universe. These limitations are further compounded by the fact that actual physics often behaves differently from its mathematical models, making the accurate bracketing of constraints difficult.

Quantum Mechanics and Relativity

Quantum mechanics and relativity, two fundamental pillars of modern physics, are both integral to our understanding of cosmology but also present their own challenges. Entanglement exhibits instantaneous properties, while the nature of time remains poorly defined. Accelerating any object results in a change in its shape, further complicating our attempts to measure and understand the universe. These and other phenomena highlight the ongoing struggle to reconcile the different aspects of physics into a cohesive theory.

The Need for Broader Perspectives

Understanding cosmology requires a multidimensional approach that encompasses all possible perspectives. No single point can be precisely defined from all perspectives due to the vastness and complexity of the universe. Theories such as string theory, quantum pilot wave theory, and quantum mechanics each offer different perspectives but often leave gaps in providing mutually consistent predictability.

The concepts of dark energy and dark matter are essential but also serve as fudge factors in our current understanding. Dark matter, in particular, represents a significant influence that is more than five times that of the conventional physics we understand. Without a comprehensive understanding of these phenomena, our tools for studying cosmology remain sparsely developed and often plagued by errors.

Conclusion

The incoherence of cosmology is not something to be lamented but rather embraced as a challenge that drives scientific progress. As we continue to refine our theories and develop new tools for observation, our understanding of the universe will evolve. The quest for a unified theory of everything remains ongoing, and with it, the promise of new insights into the creation and nature of the universe.

Keywords: cosmology, complexity, alternative theories