Why Aren't Filmmakers Hiring Actual Martial Artists for Action Choreography?

It's a common complaint among movie enthusiasts and martial artists alike that the choreography in action movies often looks fake and non-realistic. But is it really because the filmmakers aren't hiring actual martial artists, or are there other factors at play?

The Role of Martial Artists in Action Films

Real martial artists do get hired for action scenes all the time. When you mention "choreography," it implies that moves are planned and rehearsed before filming. This predictability can be a problem for martial artists who demand more realism in their performance. However, it's important to understand that films have to balance authenticity with viewer expectations and box office success.

Choreography vs. Realism

Most action scenes, especially in mainstream blockbusters, are choreographed for a reason. Directors and choreographers must consider the logistics of filming, the actions of multiple actors, and the narrative flow of the movie. While this process may lead to some predictability, it doesn't necessarily mean that the final product will look fake. Many martial artists who work in the film industry have found a way to blend their expertise with the demands of filmmaking.

Challenges of Realistic Combat in Films

The challenge of achieving realistic combat in action films is significant. Real martial artists can bring an authentic touch to these scenes, but they must navigate the constraints of filmmaking. In many cases, the action must flow smoothly and be edited to enhance the narrative, which can sometimes lead to a loss of realism.

Examples of Real Martial Artists in Action Filmmaking

Some directors, like Chad Stahelski, known for his work on The Matrix and Mission: Impossible – Fallout, have successfully incorporated real martial artists into their films. These collaborations often result in a more dynamic and convincing action sequence. However, even these productions face challenges in translating real martial arts into the fast-paced and edited nature of cinema.

Take, for instance, John Wick. The film's success lies in its meticulous choreography and the believable performances of Keanu Reeves and his cast. While the action scenes are replete with fluid and well-executed moves, the choreography remains a blend of realism and cinematic flair.

Balancing Realism and Entertainment

While movies like John Wick succeed in balancing realism with entertainment, they often prioritize the latter. The audience's reaction to an action scene is just as important as its realism. If the scene doesn't thrill, entertain, or leave a lasting impression, the film may not perform well. This is why many filmmakers opt for a combination of choreographed movements and spontaneous elements to create the illusion of authenticity.

Examples of Authenticity in Action Films

On the other hand, films like CODA, which features actual deaf actors playing themselves, have achieved critical and commercial success by embracing authenticity. This film shines a light on the real experiences of a deaf family, making it a compelling and genuine story. In a similar vein, incorporating authentic martial artists can add depth and credibility to action scenes.

Conclusion

The question of why filmmakers don't always hire martial artists for action choreography is complex. While real martial artists can bring authenticity to action scenes, the demands of filmmaking often necessitate a balance between realism and entertainment. As long as the audience is captivated and the film resonates with its intended message, it can be considered a success.

Filmmakers will continue to explore new ways to merge real martial arts with the magic of cinema, ensuring that action scenes remain both thrilling and realistic.