Which Voice from the 1960s and 1970s Was the Sweetest: Art Garfunkel or David Gates?

When it comes to the sweetest voices from the 1960s and 1970s, opinions often diverge. Some enthusiasts argue that Art Garfunkel's cover of "I Only Have Eyes For You" surpasses anything David Gates can produce. Others believe both artists have beautiful voices, but assign the edge to Art Garfunkel.

Garfunkel's range and purity of voice was, in the words of many, simply angelic. His vocal style often made Paul Simon sound like a mere sidekick, though many fans have a deep respect for Simon's work. It's not just Simon's voice that gets the comparison; Garfunkel is often described as an "artiste" himself, with a voice that seemingly elevates even the simplest notes into something truly beautiful. Some even go as far as expressing that "Art Garfunkel's Voice Was Magical."

Comparing the Range and Style

Many point out that Garfunkel had a slightly broader range compared to Gates. Moreover, David Gates was responsible for writing most of the songs he performed, which likely gave him an edge in crafting music specifically suited for his voice. However, for the discerning listener, the key factor seems to be Garfunkel's vocal purity and emotive range.

In terms of personal comparisons, it's interesting to note that readers from the period when these artists were at the height of their career, such as the late 1960s and 1970s, often had unique insights. For example, someone who graduated from high school in 1970, which is during the peak of both artists' careers, noted that their favorite songs included "Bridge Over Troubled Water" and "America," both of which showcased the depth of Garfunkel and Simon's vocals.

When evaluating which voice was the sweetest, factors such as the listener's personal taste, the specific songs performed, and the broader context of the era all play a role. While Garfunkel's range and purity often stand out, it's important to recognize the contributions of all artists.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while both Art Garfunkel and David Gates were exceptional vocalists in their own right, if we're comparing those distinct voices from the 1960s and 1970s, Art Garfunkel's voice is often cited as the sweetest and most pure of the two. His ability to elevate simple notes and melodies into something truly transcendent is a testament to his innate musical talent and the enduring appeal of his voice.

Further Reading

For more on the rich history of 1960s and 1970s music, explore articles on legendary performers such as Paul Simon and The Carpenters and how they shaped the sound of an era.

Remember that music is subjective, and what one person finds sweet or beautiful might be different for another. Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!