Understanding the Balance Between Realism and Subjective Relativism

When discussing the value of realism versus subjective relativism, one must consider the practical outcomes achieved through each approach. I affirm the importance of realism, given that my best outcomes have come from honoring the best knowable objective truths and applying pragmatism. While there is certainly nothing inherently wrong with subjective relativism, it is essential to recognize its proper place within the broader context of reality.

Our human experiences are rich with the potential to create new realities through our thought-energy and our connection to the seed of the Creative Divine within us. However, these experiential realities are still within the realm of objective realism. They operate best in a pragmatic framework, where they can be effectively utilized and applied to our lives and the world around us.

The Role of Realism in Perception and Practice

As a regional art form emerging at the turn of the 20th century, the nuances and spirit of this period resonate deeply with me, particularly in the realms of painting and literature. These artistic expressions are more akin to a subjective and personal interpretation of the world, rather than a mechanical reproduction or xerox of nature. This infused creativity and emotional depth highlight the importance of viewing reality through a lens that honors individual perspectives.

However, it is crucial to understand the line between subjective expression and the inherent nature of reality. Just as a socialist might question the realism of socialist realism itself, it is essential to recognize that the term 'realism' can be subject to interpretation and debate. The concept of 'realism' itself is fluid, and what is considered 'real' can often be a category constructed for intellectual ease.

Einstein's Insight on Reality and Its Categories

To extend a famous quote from Albert Einstein, one might say, 'you should take reality as seriously as necessary but no more seriously.' This adage acknowledges the abundance of true and authentic experiences that shape our understanding of the world. Approaching these realities with a pragmatic mindset allows us to navigate our lives effectively, without over-complicating the natural intricacies of existence.

Human beings frequently create categories for the sake of intellectual economy, simplifying complex phenomena to make them more manageable. This process is known as reification, where abstract concepts are given a concrete, tangible form. An interesting example of reification can be found in the etymology of the word 'republic.' The Latin roots of this word, 'res publiqua,' denote 'the thing of the public.' Today, we often treat a republic as if it were a real, tangible entity, when in fact it is a construct with evolving definitions.

The evolution of our categories is both practical and necessary over time. For instance, the reclassification of Pluto losing its status as a planet is a testament to the dynamic nature of these constructs. As our understanding and perspectives change, so too do the categories we use to describe the world around us. Embracing the fluidity of these categories allows us to adapt more effectively to the ever-changing landscape of reality.

The Importance of Adaptation and Flexibility

Ultimately, striking a balance between realism and subjective relativism is key to navigating the complexities of life and art. By taking reality seriously only to the extent necessary, we honor both the concrete truths and the subjective experiences that shape our lives. While subjective relativism offers a rich and diverse perspective, realism anchors us in the tangible realities that define our existence.

The interplay between these two perspectives enriches our understanding of the world, encouraging us to appreciate the beauty and complexity of both our subjective experiences and the objective truths that govern reality. In doing so, we can create a more nuanced and dynamic framework for interpreting our lives and the art that reflects it.