Procreate vs Art Studio: Which iPad App is Better for Drawing with Apple Pencil?

Choosing between Procreate and Art Studio can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to creating digital art with the Apple Pencil on an iPad Pro. Both applications offer distinct features and workflows that cater to different artistic preferences. In this article, we will explore the advantages and limitations of each app, helping you to make an informed decision based on your specific needs.

Procreate: A Timeless Favorite

I have been using Procreate since the early days of the iPad, specifically with the iPad 3. Over the years, it has become a staple in my creative arsenal. Whether it’s drawing with my finger or using an Apple Pencil, Procreate has consistently offered a seamless and intuitive experience. The app is particularly praised for its intuitive interface, extensive brush library, and robust layering capabilities. These features make it an invaluable tool for digital artists who require versatility and performance.

Art Studio: A Comprehensive Toolset

Art Studio, on the other hand, is known for its comprehensive set of tools and features tailored for professional-level artwork creation. The app supports advanced layer management, customizable brushes, and a wide range of file formats. If you are a professional artist looking to produce high-quality drawings and paintings, Art Studio could be the ideal choice. It offers a robust selection of tools that cater to various artistic needs, making it a versatile option for your creative endeavors.

Differences and Personal Experiences

While both apps support the Apple Pencil and its tilt and pressure features, there are notable differences in their implementations. For instance, Procreate is often touted for its ability to perform about 90% of what most people need from an app. However, I have noticed that the tilt feature in Procreate often behaves unpredictably. A small adjustment in the angle can cause the effect to be either fully on or fully off, which might not suit everyone equally.

Art Studio, conversely, has some notable issues with palm rejection, leading to the appearance of little dots on the screen when the wrist is close to the display. This can be frustrating, especially when meticulous drawing is required. Despite these challenges, Art Studio excels in areas like selections, filters, text, and exporting, which are not as well-supported by other applications.

Recent Developments

Art Studio Pro, released more recently, has undergone a major rewrite. It is possible that some of the issues mentioned earlier have been resolved. However, it is advisable to keep an eye on the latest updates and feedback from users to ensure that the app has improved.

Experimentation and Conclusion

The ideal app ultimately depends on an artist's specific needs and preferences. To make an informed decision, it is recommended to experiment with both Procreate and Art Studio. You can try out a variety of tools and features in each app to determine which one aligns more closely with your creative workflow.

Whether you prefer the versatility and performance of Procreate or the comprehensive toolset of Art Studio, the key is to find the app that best suits your artistic style and goals. By understanding the differences and exploring the features of each app, you can make a well-informed choice that will enhance your digital drawing experiences with the Apple Pencil on iPad Pro.