Photographing the Amish: Customs and Traditions

Is it okay to take pictures of the Amish? The answer to this question is a little more complicated than a simple yes or no. This cultural group, known for their simple way of life, has unique beliefs and customs surrounding photography. Understanding these beliefs is important for both respect and etiquette.

Amish Beliefs and Photography

The Amish, descendants of Swiss Anabaptists, have specific beliefs regarding photography. Many within this community believe that taking a photograph steals a person's soul, a notion rooted in old superstitions and supernatural fears. These beliefs are deeply ingrained and can vary based on the strictness of the group.

Historical Context and Modern Practices

Historically, the Amish considered photographs to be "graven images" forbidden by the Ten Commandments. As a result, photography was largely avoided. However, with the increasing use of cell phones and other modern technology, the taboo is gradually fading. More and more Amish are now willing to have their pictures taken, even if they still avoid posing for them.

It's worth noting that the degree of acceptance can vary greatly. In the most strict groups like the Schwartzentruber Amish, photography may still be entirely prohibited. However, in more lenient communities, photographs can be taken and even shared as long as they are not used for commercial or vanity purposes.

Respect and Etiquette

Even as the taboo is fading, it's crucial to respect the Amish's customs and beliefs. Always ask for permission before taking a photograph. Approach the situation with sensitivity, recognizing that the Amish may be overwhelmed by the idea of being captured on camera, especially if they see themselves as a "strange" or "other" group.

A useful comparison is to think about how you would feel if a stranger asked to take your picture while you were going about your daily routine. Many people, including the Amish, might find the experience invasive or uncomfortable.

Personal Experiences

One of my own experiences involved a trip to Amish country in Pennsylvania. During the visit, my grandfather was attempting to take a photograph of an Amish dairy driver, who instead of agreeing, removed the film from the camera. This incident highlights both the dangers of assuming familiarity and the importance of respecting the Amish's customs.

I also recall an encounter where a young girl in traditional attire was selling flowers at a farmer's market. I asked if she and her sister would be willing to pose for a picture. To my surprise, they readily agreed, realizing they might not have a chance to see their likeness in print due to their isolation from modern media.

Conclusion

Photographing Amish individuals can be a sensitive issue, but the key is respect and understanding. Always seek permission and approach the situation with empathy. While strict Amish communities may still avoid photography, in more accepting environments, a single permission and genuine interest can make all the difference.