Nathuram Godse: The Patriot Lost in Shadow of Mahatma Gandhi

Among the myriad figures of Indian history, some stand taller than others, seemingly immune to criticism. However, the case of Nathuram Godse is one that challenges the conventional narratives we have been taught. Many view Mahatma Gandhi as the ultimate icon of patriotism, selflessness, and the freedom movement. Yet, the story of Nathuram Godse reveals a different facet of patriotism and decision-making in the mire of history.

Comparing Intentions: Selflessness and Nationalism

One of the primary reasons some argue in favor of Nathuram Godse is the sheer selflessness of his intentions. Unlike Gandhi, who often prioritized his popularity and the well-being of the collective, Godse was prepared to sacrifice his own popularity, goodwill, and respect in society for the greater good of the nation. This sacrificial approach is a hallmark of true patriotism, where personal gain is set aside in the face of a more pressing national need.

A Legacy Shadowed: Congress and Its Propaganda

The political climate of the time played a significant role in shaping public perception. Congress, a British-founded and British-funded party, had a keen interest in promoting its own leaders and criticizing those of the opposition. This continued both during and after India's independence, with Congress consistently depicting itself as the sole savior and all others as enemies. This narrative has had a lasting impact, sidelining figures like Nathuram Godse who, despite their noble intentions, were not part of the official historical narratives.

Godse's Unfolding Story

Nathuram Godse was more than just a rumor of a hitman; he was a well-educated editor and a respected figure in his field. During a critical period in India's history, when Nizams and their razakars were perpetrating heinous acts, Godse, as part of an RSS delegation, went to Hyderabad. Despite facing immense physical and emotional challenges, including a brutal flogging, he remained resolute in his convictions. His story is one of sacrifice and selfless service, often overshadowed by the larger-than-life figure of Mahatma Gandhi.

Challenging Gandhi's Decisions

Godse's decision to assassinate Gandhi was deeply rooted in his belief that Gandhi's actions had played a significant role in the tragic events of partition. He was particularly saddened by Gandhi's:

A weak stand on the partition issue, which he believed exacerbated the violence and suffering of the people involved.

Encouragement of Muslims to leave India without moral support, as opposed to the weak response to Hindu refugees.

Condemnation of historical figures who fought for self-defense, like Maharana Pratap, Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj, or Guru Govind Singh.

Godse's arguments highlight the complex and often contradictory nature of historical figures and the impact of their decisions on the lives of millions.

Posthumous Recognition and Controversy

Aftr Godse's execution, the Congress party tried to suppress the truth about his motives and statements. However, in recent times, Godse's viewpoints have been more openly discussed. Books like 'Why I Killed Gandhi' and films such as the Limelight OTT platform's recent release have provided insights into his perspectives. Today, we are left to debate whether Nathuram Godse was a patriot greater than Mahatma Gandhi or if the nuances of history have been lost in the shadows of a more popular narrative.

The legacy of Nathuram Godse remains a controversial topic, but his story invites us to re-examine the complexities of history and the true intentions of those who have shaped it. Whether we admire or despise his actions, Godse's story is a reminder that history is far from monolithic and that every figure has a story worth untangling.