Is Gandhi’s Pacifism Consistent with Christian Values?

Recently, I had a conversation with Jesus, and he shared his thoughts on Mahatma Gandhi’s pacifist stance. Unlike Gandhi, Jesus did not believe that non-violence meant passively accepting injustice. Instead, he took a bold and active stance against the status quo, as seen in his actions against the merchants in the temple and the symbolic act of being crucified.

Contrasting Gandhi’s and Jesus’ Approaches

Mahatma Gandhi, known for his non-violent resistance, believed his utopian vision could overcome British rule. However, this approach might not align with the core teachings of Christ as interpreted by early Church fathers like St. Augustine and St. Clement. They supported the just war theory, advocating for the justified use of violence in defense of the innocent.

In contrast, Gandhi often manipulated Christ's teachings to fit his own utopian vision. He relied on a form of non-violence known as ahimsa, which strictly prohibits violence. Yet, this approach may be too absolutist and fail to address complex realities that require a deeper understanding of biblical principles.

The Role of Courage in Christianity

Jesus demonstrated courage by confronting power and injustice. Motivated by love and a desire for justice, he was willing to face persecution and death to defend the poor and the oppressed. This example challenges the idea that being a Christian means sitting idly by and doing nothing.

While Gandhi’s message of non-violence resonates with many, it is essential to consider the broader context. True pacifism must also include the rejection of violence while actively working for peace and justice. This often requires taking a stand, as Jesus did, which may involve conflict but for the sake of righteousness.

The Current State of Christianity and War

Today, tensions and conflicts rage in over thirty countries. Many of those involved in these wars claim to be Christians. Yet, the Bible, particularly John 17:14, emphasizes that true Christians should not partake in these conflicts. This verse suggests that true Christians follow the ways of Jesus, who left this world not to condemnation but to life and truth.

It is important to note that while Catholicism traces its roots back to Christ, there is a significant difference between it and some evangelical or born-again Christian denominations. These latter groups can be intolerant, self-promoting, and even cult-like, often disregarding other forms of Christianity like Catholicism. Their approach to Christianity can be seen as a form of extremism that goes against Christ’s values of love and inclusivity.

Ultimately, the question of whether Gandhi’s pacifism aligns with Christian values is complex and requires a nuanced approach. While non-violence can be a powerful tool for justice and peace, it should be grounded in a deep understanding of biblical principles and the courage to stand up for what is right, even when it means being met with opposition.