Cultural Appropriation and the Wearing of Saris/Cholis in the USA: Debunking Misconceptions

The concept of cultural appropriation is often misunderstood and overused in discussions regarding the adoption of clothing and cultural symbols across different communities. One such example brings into question whether wearing a sari or choli in the USA can be considered a form of cultural appropriation. The answer is: it is not, and here's why.

Understanding Cultural Appropriation

Herein lies the crux of cultural appropriation: the act of adopting elements of an outside culture, often from a minority group, without understanding or respecting the original culture and its context. However, it is important to recognize that this term has been continuously misused and applied incorrectly by individuals who might be uncomfortable acknowledging that all cultures today are a product of a complex process of absorption, adaptation, and modification from surrounding and past cultures.

Historical Context and Inheritance of Culture

The modern existence and manifestation of all cultural elements—art, language, architecture, clothing, music, food, religions, beliefs, philosophy, fashion, science, sports, technology, governing systems, social behavior, institutions, and norms—are a result of this ongoing exchange and transformation. What we see today as unique and distinct is merely some form of modification, with outcomes that can be better or worse than what has preceded them. Crucially, there is no patent or trademark on cultural aspects. Therefore, to apply cultural appropriation to a situation like wearing a sari or choli without full understanding and respect is to undervalue the dynamic nature of cultural evolution.

American Context Specifics

In the USA, cultural diversity is the norm. This diversity is built on a long history of immigration, where people from various cultural backgrounds have brought their traditions and customs to the country. As a result, many cultural elements are not exclusive to any one group but have become part of a shared American cultural tapestry. Wearing a sari or choli in these contexts is more likely to be seen as a personal preference or fashion choice, rather than an appropriation of the cultural symbols.

Examples of Non-Appropriate Cultural Elements

Consider the popularity of yoga in the USA. Yoga, a practice with roots in Hinduism, has been widely adopted by Americans without significant negative backlash. Similarly, the use of aromatherapy, meditation, and various traditional Eastern practices have become common in American culture, often without being considered appropriation.

The Intent Behind Adoptions and Wearing

Moreover, most individuals who choose to wear a sari or choli do so not with the intent to disrespect or appropriate but out of admiration, curiosity, or personal preference. People often see such clothing as a way to appreciate and learn about other cultures, much like traveling or reading about different cultures. Such acts of wearing cannot be equated with a lack of understanding and respect.

Conclusion: The Educational Aspect

While it is true that many aspects of culture are appropriated without full understanding and respect, this does not make it inherently wrong. In many cases, the vast majority of cultural elements are acquired, not out of malice or disrespect, but simply because people like certain aspects of a culture, whether it is the aesthetics of a sari or the intricacies of a choli. This is where education and open dialogue play a crucial role.

Encouraging Positive Cultural Exchange

To enhance the appreciation and understanding of different cultures, it is essential to promote education and mutual respect. By engaging in open conversations and promoting cultural diversity, we can foster a society that values cultural evolution and adaptation while diminishing the negative connotations associated with cultural appropriation.