Creating Art: For Myself or for the Market?
Introduction
Art creation is a highly personal endeavor, and the mindset behind it can greatly influence the outcome of one’s works. In this article, we explore the perspective of an artist who prioritizes self-expression over commercial success. Through his experiences and insights, we aim to understand the motivations behind different approaches to art creation and their implications.
Art Creation as a Personal Venture
As an artist, I firmly believe that my art should represent my inner narrative and emotions. I create for myself, rather than for art collectors or the everyday person. My work carries personal significance that extends beyond its potential to sell. For instance, when I draw, I immerse myself in a world that only I see, weaving in elements that convey my own story and emotions. This perspective is encapsulated in Lee Ballentine's sentiment that art is created to be meaningful to the creator, regardless of its marketability.
Understanding the Roles: Fine Artist vs. Illustrator
To better understand this viewpoint, it's essential to distinguish between a fine artist and an illustrator. An illustrator is primarily driven by a specific brief or market demand, aiming to present the outward appearance of a subject clearly. In contrast, a fine artist focuses more on capturing the internal essence or emotion of the subject. For example, when I draw an animal, I might include minute details that feel realistic, such as out-of-place hairs, which might be seen as a distraction by an illustrator.
Examples to Illustrate the Difference
Two illustrative examples might help clarify the differences:
The Warreners
The Warreners are a breed often portrayed as cuddly pets. However, my interest lies in their original purpose of hunting badgers. This work emphasizes the rawness and strength of the breed, rather than their cuddly nature.
The Barn Patrol
While The Barn Patrol had commercial considerations, these did not compromise my artistic vision. When illustrating a Cairn Terrier, I focused on the personal artistic elements rather than adhering strictly to a commercial palette. For instance, using different shades in a drawing can lead to interesting results and interpretations.
A Personal Experience with Commercial Success
Years ago, I was recognized as the top-selling UK canine artist based on print sales. This recognition led to increased competition from other artists and publishers. However, my approach remained centered on personal expression rather than commercial appeal. The striking difference in quality between my work and that of the competitors highlighted the importance of soul and creativity in art, which is often overshadowed by sales numbers.
Currently, I am a painting student, but I have already identified some works that could potentially sell well. My approach remains unchanged; I paint what I like and let the market decide. If those works sell for a significant amount, I would be motivated to produce more. This balance between personal satisfaction and market demand is crucial in maintaining the integrity of one’s art.
Conclusion
The question of whether to create art for oneself or the market remains a personal one. My journey has shown that balancing personal expression and market demand can lead to compelling and meaningful works of art.