Choosing the Right Instrument: Piano or Guitar for a 13-Year-Old Girl

As someone who has played the piano, I could say it is the better choice. However, the decision ultimately depends on the individual's interests, preferences, and goals. Whether it's piano, guitar, or even a ukulele, the most important thing is to find an instrument that resonates with her and brings joy.

Unique Benefits of Piano and Guitar

Both the piano and guitar offer unique benefits for a 13-year-old girl. Piano players are often associated with a solid foundation in music theory and would benefit from a structured learning environment. Meanwhile, guitars provide versatility and opportunities for self-expression, allowing individuality to shine through. Encourage her to try both instruments before making a decision, as this can help her determine which one resonates more with her.

Factors to Consider

Interest and Preference: Which instrument does she feel drawn to? Music Theory vs. Self-Expression: Is she more interested in learning music theory or expressing herself through her music? User-Friendliness: Piano learning can be both easier and more challenging initially, with a higher learning curve compared to a guitar. Portability: Guitars are more portable, making them easier to carry around and play in different settings.

Start with What Resonates Most

Begin with the instrument that she feels the most drawn to. Whether it's a piano, guitar, or even a ukulele, the first step should be enjoyable and engaging. Once she has gained some experience, she can explore other options. Starting with a piano can be beneficial as it lays a solid foundation, whereas starting with a guitar can provide immediate satisfaction and fun.

Interesting Insights

Starting with the ukulele can be an excellent way for beginners, as it is a guitar-like instrument that is highly portable. It’s a fun and easy way for her to start learning basic music skills before moving on to a more complex instrument.

Neither instrument is mutually exclusive. As an example, I play the guitar now and thoroughly enjoy it. However, looking back on my piano lessons, I regret not putting more effort into it. Piano lessons as a child could have provided a better foundation now. My current love for the guitar makes me realize that I might be even better at it if I had strengthened my piano skills earlier. So, don't dismiss an instrument solely because it seems too hard or annoying. Every instrument has its unique charm and benefits.

Final Thoughts

My advice is simple: listen to examples of both instruments, whether on YouTube or in person. Encourage her to explore both and determine which one feels the most resonant with her. Whether she starts with a guitar or a piano, the key is to find the instrument that brings her joy and inspires her to continue learning and developing her musical skills.

Remember, there is no wrong answer. Whatever she chooses, make sure it is a win-win situation. In the worst-case scenario, she will gain valuable experience on an excellent instrument, paving the way for continued growth and enjoyment.