Bach or Beethoven: A Personal Revelation in Music Taste

When it comes to music preferences, two historical figures stand out: Johann Sebastian Bach and Ludwig van Beethoven. While some are captivated by Beethoven's raw emotion, drama, and awe-inspiring compositions, others like myself find more solace in Bach's refined and profound music.

Bach: The Perfectionist

Bach, a master who bridged and refined all the musical traditions of his time, is a composer whose work is both intricate and deeply human. His compositions often convey a genuine, passionate connection between the listener and the music. The creator of conflicted advancement in the classical genre, his music feels more like the creation of a flesh-and-blood man. While Beethoven stands out as a revolutionary who breaks rules and seeks new horizons, Bach's works embody a sense of timelessness and perfection. My preference for Bach stems from the relatable and grounding nature of his compositions.

Beethoven: The Embodiment of Revolution

Beethoven, on the other hand, is the embodiment of revolution in music. His constant breaking of rules and ceaseless creation of new forms set him apart. He saw himself as a distinguished artist who was separate from other men. His music is often characterized by its intensity and personal bravado, which can sometimes appear egotistical and attention-seeking. While Beethoven's compositions are undoubtedly magnificent, my personal inclination leans towards the mellowness and complexity of Bach's music.

Perspectives on Listening Preferences

Listening preferences are subjective and deeply rooted in individual experiences and contexts. My perspective is that of a non-professional, meaning I have no formal training in music history or theory. My preferences align with the sentiments of Mark Needham, where both Bach and Beethoven are respected and cherished for their distinct contributions.

Beethoven as Intense Coffee

To compare the listening experience, I often liken listening to Beethoven to drinking coffee. Coffee is intense and not for daily consumption; it's enjoyed in moments of unique desire or when you genuinely appreciate its robust flavors and aromas. Similarly, Beethoven's music is intense and powerful, making it difficult to listen to frequently or in every context. It is the kind of music that should be savored, much like a cup of strong coffee. However, many prefer to incorporate Bach's music into their daily life, much like a gentle and comforting cup of tea.

Bach as Pure Tea

Bach, in contrast, is often compared to pure tea—elegant, nuanced, and versatile. Bach's music is more subdued yet profoundly moving, making it an ideal accompaniment to a variety of activities and contexts. I frequently use Bach's music in the background during other activities, much like one might savor tea in small sips while reading or working. Beethoven's music, however, is too intense and demanding for such occasions. It demands full attention, much like how coffee is enjoyed in moments of intense focus or pleasure.

Conclusion: Each Composer Has Its Unique Role

Ultimately, both Bach and Beethoven are integral to the classical music canon. Each composer serves a distinct purpose and fulfills a unique role in the musical landscape. Bach's music is perfect for those who seek subtlety, depth, and a sense of timelessness. Beethoven, on the other hand, is the choice for those who appreciate grandeur, drama, and emotional intensity. No one should consider one to be better than the other; the right music depends on the right occasion and the listener's personal taste.

Additional Notes

It's worth noting that initial perceptions can be misleading. If one listens to Bach, especially if they are expecting a great composer, it can be a bit of a letdown. The music might seem 'mundane' at first glance. This was my initial reaction when delving into Bach's compositions. Later, as one's understanding and tastes evolve, the true complexity and beauty of Bach's music become more apparent.